Hot Water Showdown: Traditional vs. Tankless Water Heaters for Marshfield, MO Homeowners

residentialcomfort • October 21, 2024
A person is fixing a water heater in a bathroom.

When it comes to hot water heaters, Springfield area homeowners have two main options: traditional tank-style heaters and tankless heaters. Both systems have their pros and cons, and choosing the right one for your home depends on your specific needs and preferences. In this article, we'll compare traditional and tankless hot water heaters to help you make an informed decision about which option is best suited for your household.

  1. Operation and Design: Traditional hot water heaters feature a large storage tank that holds a predetermined amount of hot water, typically ranging from 30 to 80 gallons. These tanks continuously heat the water to maintain a consistent temperature, ensuring hot water is readily available whenever needed. In contrast, tankless hot water heaters, also known as on-demand or instantaneous heaters, heat water directly as it passes through the unit without the need for a storage tank. This on-demand heating system eliminates standby heat loss, making tankless heaters more energy-efficient than their traditional counterparts.
  2. Energy Efficiency: One of the key advantages of tankless hot water heaters is their superior energy efficiency. Because they only heat water as needed, tankless heaters consume less energy compared to traditional heaters, which constantly maintain a reservoir of hot water. According to the U.S. Department of Energy, tankless water heaters can be up to 34% more energy-efficient for homes that use less than 41 gallons of hot water daily. However, for homes with higher hot water demands, the energy savings may be less significant.
  3. Space Requirements: Traditional hot water heaters require a significant amount of space for installation due to their large storage tanks. This can be a limiting factor for homeowners with smaller spaces, especially in tiny homes or condominiums. On the other hand, tankless water heaters are much more compact and can be mounted on walls or installed in tight spaces, making them ideal for homes where space is at a premium.
  4. Hot Water Output: While traditional hot water heaters can provide a continuous supply of hot water as long as the tank has not been depleted, they may struggle to keep up with high-demand situations, such as multiple showers running simultaneously. Tankless water heaters, on the other hand, can deliver a virtually unlimited supply of hot water on demand, making them ideal for households with high hot water usage or large families.
  5. Initial Cost and Long-Term Savings: Tankless hot water heaters typically have a higher upfront installation cost compared to traditional heaters due to their advanced technology and installation requirements. However, they offer potential long-term savings through lower energy bills and reduced maintenance costs. Traditional heaters may have a lower initial cost but can be less efficient and more costly to operate over time, especially if they require frequent repairs or replacement.

Choosing between a traditional and tankless hot water heater depends on various factors, including your household's hot water usage, space constraints, and budget. While traditional heaters offer a familiar and reliable solution, tankless heaters provide greater energy efficiency, space savings, and on-demand hot water delivery. Consider your priorities and consult with a professional to determine which option is best suited for your home's needs. Whether you opt for the tried-and-true reliability of a traditional heater or the energy-saving benefits of a tankless system, you'll be sure to enjoy a steady supply of hot water for years to come.

The logo for residential comfort pros shows a person 's feet in a bathtub.

Ready to upgrade your hot water system and enjoy reliable, energy-efficient performance? Trust our team of experts at Residential Comfort Pros for professional installation of traditional or tankless water heaters in Springfield, MO metro area! Whether you prefer the convenience of a tankless unit or the reliability of a traditional system, we'll help you choose the perfect solution for your home and ensure a seamless installation process. Don't settle for lukewarm showers or high energy bills—contact us today to schedule your water heater installation and start enjoying endless hot water whenever you need it!

DIY vs. Professional Plumbing Repairs: Know When to Call a Plumber.  A guide by Residential Comfort
By Dale Napier March 17, 2025
Not sure if you should tackle that plumbing repair yourself or call a pro? Our latest blog breaks down common DIY fixes and when it’s best to call Residential Comfort Pros in Bolivar, MO to handle the job. Save time, money, and stress—read now!
Illustration of HVAC financing process, showing cost breakdown, payment plans, and benefits of energ
By Dale Napier February 12, 2025
Thinking about upgrading your HVAC system but worried about the cost? Our latest blog, "Understanding How HVAC Financing Works," breaks down your financing options, including 0% financing through Residential Comfort Pros. Learn how to spread out payments, take advantage of rebates, and make a smart investment in your home's comfort and efficiency. Don't let budget concerns hold you back—explore your options today!
Open air vent in a home, symbolizing proper airflow for HVAC efficiency
By Dale Napier January 10, 2025
Did you know that closing your vents could be harming your HVAC system and reducing your home's comfort? Our latest blog explains why keeping your vents open is essential for maintaining efficiency, preventing system damage, and ensuring consistent airflow throughout your home. Don’t miss these valuable tips to protect your investment and enjoy year-round comfort!
New Construction Duct Work
By Jennifer Foster December 20, 2024
As a Springfield, MO homeowner, you rely on your HVAC system to keep your home comfortable year-round. While you may be familiar with the basics of heating and cooling units, the ductwork that distributes air throughout your home often remains a mystery. In this blog post, we'll explore the essential role that ductwork plays in your HVAC system and how it functions to maintain optimal indoor comfort.
A person is using a clamp meter to check a heater.
By residentialcomfort November 21, 2024
Learn the essential signs your HVAC system requires professional maintenance. From reduced airflow to strange noises, our guide helps you stay proactive. Trust Residential Comfort Pros for expert HVAC maintenance in Bolivar, MO.
Two capacitors are sitting on top of an air conditioner.
By residentialcomfort September 15, 2024
Discover the benefits of HVAC maintenance agreements: save money, ensure comfort, and enjoy peace of mind with regular servicing. Learn more and schedule your appointment today for HVAC maintenance in Buffalo MO.
An air conditioner is sitting on the side of a brick building.
By residentialcomfort July 22, 2024
Discover the future of HVAC systems in Springfield, MO with R-454B refrigerant. Learn about its environmental benefits, energy efficiency, and how leading manufacturers are embracing this sustainable technology. Explore why transitioning to R-454B could enhance your home's comfort and reduce your carbon footprint.
A man is cleaning an air conditioner on a wall.
By residentialcomfort June 13, 2024
6 Ways to Improve Your Home's Air Quality - HVAC maintenance in Lebanon, MO
A black thermostat with the number 69 on it.
By residentialcomfort May 29, 2024
Benefits of a Programmable or WiFi Thermostat installation in Springfield, MO
Share by: